Login / Register

Enter Your Address

ADDRESS Please enter your address
Prodigy Burger Bar - E96th/Gray

Prodigy Burger Bar - E96th/Gray

 
Information
Prodigy Burger Bar - E96th/Gray

Prodigy Burger Bar - E96th/Gray

3905 E 96th St Ste C, Indianapolis, IN 46240
 

Ordering Hours
Sunday11 AM - 8:30 PM
Monday11 AM - 8:30 PM
Tuesday11 AM - 8:30 PM
Wednesday11 AM - 8:30 PM
Thursday11 AM - 8:30 PM
Friday11 AM - 9:30 PM
Saturday11 AM - 9:30 PM

Most Popular  

Side - Truffle Fries
$5.20
Side - Mac & Cheese
$5.20

Appetizers  

Before burgers.

Appetizer - Dynamite Shrimp
Beer-battered, deep-fried shrimp, coated in our delicious dynamite sauce served & over a bed of Asian slaw.
$18.14
Appetizer - In A Pickle
Crispy beer-battered pickle spears with ranch.
$11.64
Appetizer - Prodigy Nachos
House-fried tortilla chips, topped with ground chorizo, queso blanco, salsa, pickled jalapeños, sour cream, & guacamole.
$17.49
Appetizer - White Cheddar Cheese Curds
Battered crispy, white cheddar cheese curds, with a side of ranch.
$10.99
Appetizer - BYO Dip Trio
House-fried tortilla chips served with your choice of 3 dips.
$16.84
Appetizer - Soft Pretzel
Three salted pretzels, served with your choice of house-made queso or honey mustard dipping sauce.
$11.64
Appetizer - Beer Battered Onion Rings
Beer battered onion rings, finished with prodigy dust & served with our signature sauce.
$10.99
Appetizer - 6 Traditional Wings
Bone-in wings, with your choice of sauce or seasoning, served with carrots & celery.
$11.64
Appetizer - 12 Traditional Wings
Bone-in wings, with your choice of sauce or seasoning, served with carrots & celery.
$16.84
Appetizer - 18 Traditional Wings
Bone-in wings, with your choice of sauce or seasoning, served with carrots & celery.
$23.34

Greens (Salads) & Wraps  

Greens - Caesar Salad
Chopped romaine & iceberg lettuce, tossed in caesar dressing, topped with croutons & parmesan cheese. Add chicken, shrimp, & salmon, for extra charge.
$10.99
Greens - Buffalo Chicken Salad
Crispy fried buffalo tenders served on a bed of romaine lettuce, with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, & your dressing selection.
$18.79
Greens - Seasonal Salad
Arcadian blend, apples, cranberries, candied pecans, & goat cheese, served with apple vinaigrette.
$12.94
Greens - Salmon Salad
Grilled salmon on a bed of arcadian blend, topped with peaches, oranges, freshly shredded beets, & goat cheese, served with sesame ginger dressing. Substitute chicken breast.
$19.44
Greens - Ty Cobb Salad
Romaine, topped with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumbers, red onions, & your choice of dressing.
$19.44
Wrap - Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy fried buffalo chicken tenders, served on a sun-dried tomato wrap, with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, & your dressing selection.
$18.79
Wrap - Caesar Wrap
Chopped romaine & iceberg lettuce, tossed in caesar dressing, topped with croutons & parmesan cheese, in a sun-dried tomato wrap. Add chicken, shrimp, & salmon, for extra charge.
$10.99
Wrap - Seasonal Wrap
Arcadian blend, apples, cranberries, candied pecans, & goat cheese, served with apple vinaigrette.
$12.94
Wrap - Ty Cobb Wrap
Romaine, topped with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumbers, & red onion, in a sun-dried tomato wrap, with your choice of dressing.
$19.44
Wrap - Salmon Wrap
Grilled salmon on a bed of arcadian blend, topped with peaches, oranges, freshly shredded beets, & goat cheese, served with sesame ginger dressing. Substitute chicken breast.
$19.44

Not Burgers  

Not Burger - Hoosier Daddy Sandwich
An Indiana favorite. Hand-breaded, deep-fried pork tenderloin, topped with dill pickle chips on a house bun.
$18.79
Not Burger - BLT With A Twist
A heap of bacon, lettuce, & tomato, topped with garlic aioli between two slices of Texas toast.
$16.84
Not Burger - Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Hand-breaded, deep-fried chicken breast, drenched in buffalo sauce, with ranch & bleu cheese mousse, on a signature bun.
$18.79
Not Burger - Adult Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Two slices of Texas toast toasted to perfection, with parmesan cheese, goat cheese, spicy marinara, & fried provolone.
$18.14
Not Burger - Italian Beef Sandwich
Shredded Italian beef, dipped in au jus & topped with giardiniera.
$19.44
Not Burger - Jerk Chicken Sandwich
A jerk-seasoned grilled chicken breast, with pineapple salsa on a signature bun.
$18.79
Not Burger - Chicken Tenders Basket
Beer-battered chicken tenders, served with fries & a dipping sauce of your choice.
$18.79
Not Burger - Teriyaki Salmon
Grilled, teriyaki-glazed salmon, over a bed of Asian slaw, alongside fresh, steamed broccoli.
$20.09
Not Burger - Spinach Mac & Cheese
Our signature mac & cheese, blended with house-made spinach dip & sautéed mushrooms, topped with crumbled goat cheese & grated parmesan, served with a slice of Texas toast.
$18.14
Not Burger - Buffalo Mac & Cheese
Our signature mac & cheese, mixed with buffalo chicken dip, topped with bleu cheese crumbles & two hand-dipped buffalo chicken tenders, served with a slice of Texas toast. Grilled chicken or fried chicken breast.
$19.44
Not Burger - Chili Mac
Our signature mac & cheese, with prodigy chili, pickled jalapeños, minced onion, a sour cream drizzle, & a shredded cheese topping, served with a slice of Texas toast.
$19.44
Not Burger - Windy City
Nathan's famous all beef hot dog, topped with tomato, relish, a pickle spear, chopped onions, mustard, & celery salt, on a poppy seed bun.
$12.94
Not Burger - Southern Indiana
Prodigy chili, queso blanco, minced onions, & shredded cheddar, over a nathan's famous all beef hot dog, on a poppy seed bun.
$12.94
Not Burger - Fish & Chips (3 pcs)
$22.04

Smash Burgers  

Smash Burger - Classic Smash Burger
American cheese & Prodigy sauce, on a signature bun.
$16.84
Smash Burger - Bacon & Bleu Smash Burger
Bacon, seasoned fries, bleu cheese mousse, & buffalo sauce.
$18.14
Smash Burger - Mushroom & Swiss Smash Burger
Swiss cheese & sautéed mushrooms, on our signature house bun, topped with truffle mayo.
$18.14
Smash Burger - Prodigy Melt Smash Burger
Two smash patties, American cheese, caramelized onions, & Prodigy sauce, between two slices of Texas toast.
$18.14
Smash Burger - Mac & Cheese Burger
American cheese, bacon, & garlic aioli, topped with signature mac & cheese.
$18.79
Smash Burger - Jamaican Black Bean Burger
Jerk-seasoned black bean burger, pineapple salsa, & pepper jack cheese, all on a signature bun.
$16.84
Smash Burger - Juicy Lucy Smash Burger
A double smash burger, with provolone cheese between the patties, American cheese, bacon, & Prodigy sauce, served on a signature bun.
$22.04
Smash Burger - Chicago Burger
A single smash patty, served with Italian beef, provolone cheese, giardiniera, tomato aioli, & a side of au jus.
$16.84
Smash Burger - Peanut Butter Cheddar Burger
Two smash burgers, with cheddar, pickled jalapeños, & peanut butter, on a signature bun.
$18.14
Smash Burger - Mexican Burger
Chorizo, green chile salsa, guacamole, & pickled jalapeños, on top of two smash burgers with pepper jack, served on a signature bun.
$19.44

Signature Burgers  

Signature Burger - Bacon & Cheddar Signature Burger
Thick-cut bacon, cheddar cheese, & Prodigy sauce, on a sesame bun.
$23.34
Signature Burger - Fried Egg & Bacon
Our award-winning burger: fried egg, thick-cut bacon, tater tots, & queso.
$23.34
Signature Burger - No Name Burger
$23.34
Signature Burger - Steak Burger
A-1 steak sauce, sautéed mushrooms, & onions, served with provolone cheese & a creamy horseradish.
$23.34
Signature Burger - Kimcheeseburger
Sautéed peppers & onions, kimchi, Korean bbq sauce & American cheese, served on a sesame bun.
$23.34
Signature Burger - Gut Buster
Chili, queso, minced onion, pickled jalapenos, & sour cream, served on top of a grilled cheese, on Texas toast.
$23.34
Signature Burger - Signature Sliders
Sampler-sized sliders, featuring the no name, steak burger, & bacon & cheddar.
$20.74

Create Your Own Masterpiece  

Create Your Own Masterpiece - Build Your Own
$0.00

Featured Options  

Featured Option - Black & Blue Salad
Sliced sirloin steak, arcadian mix, cherry tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, pickled red onions, & giardiniera, served with blueberry balsamic dressing.
$21.39
Featured Option - Mediterranean Salad
Chopped romaine, cucumber, grape tomatoes, pickled red onion, fried chickpeas, & goat cheese, served with lemon tahini dressing.
$15.54
Featured Option - The Philly Cheesesteak
Sliced sirloin, sautéed with peppers, onions, & mushrooms, topped with provolone cheese, all on a hoagie.
$18.79
Featured Option - Steak Sandwich
Sliced sirloin, pickled red onions, & creamy horseradish, served on Texas toast.
$19.44
Featured Option - Steak & Fries
A 6 oz sirloin, seasoned & grilled to perfection, served with an order of Prodigy dusted fries.
$19.44
Featured Option - Grilled Chicken & Chorizo
Grilled chicken, chorizo, sautéed peppers & onions, with cavatappi pasta & green chili queso, served with Texas toast & garnished with pickled jalapeños.
$19.44

Sides  

Next to burgers.

Side - Fries
$3.90
Side - Truffle Fries
$5.20
Side - Sweet Potato Fries
$5.20
Side - Tater Tots
$5.20
Side - Onion Rings
$5.20
Side - Cup Of Chili
$3.90
Side - Cole Slaw
$3.90
Side - Broccoli
$5.20
Side - Fruit
$5.20
Side - Mac & Cheese
$5.20
Side - House Salad
$5.20
Side - Caesar Salad
$5.20
Side - Loaded Tater Tots
$7.15
Side - Loaded Fries
$5.85
Side - Loaded Sweet Fries
$7.15
Side - Asian Slaw
$3.90

Kids' Meals  

Kids under 11. Price includes soda & choice of side.

Kids' Meal - Kids' Grilled Cheese
American cheese sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast.
$6.50
Kids' Meal - Kids' Smash
A thinly smashed patty, topped with American cheese & a side.
$6.50
Kids' Meal - Kids' Cheese Curd
Our crispy cheese curds, served with french fries & ranch dipping sauce.
$6.50
Kids' Meal - Kids' Mac & Cheese
$6.50
Kids' Meal - Kids' Chicken Tenders
Our crispy tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce.
$6.50

Desserts  

Dessert - Ice Cream (Scoop)
Vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry ice cream.
$2.93
Dessert - Peanut Butter Cake
$7.74
Dessert - Chocolate Chip Cookie Milk Cake
$7.74

Beverages  

Beverage - Coke
$3.90
Beverage - Diet Coke
$3.90
Beverage - Coke Zero
$3.90
Beverage - Sprite
$3.90
Beverage - Lemonade
$3.90
Beverage - Fanta Orange
$3.90
Beverage - Mr Pibb
$3.90
Beverage - Mellow Yellow
$3.90
Beverage - Ginger Ale
$3.90
Beverage - Root Beer
$3.90
Beverage - Milk
$3.90
Beverage - Red Bull
$5.85
Beverage - Sugar Free Red Bull
$5.85
Beverage - Orange Juice
$3.90
Beverage - Sweet Tea
$3.90
Beverage - Ice Tea
$3.90
Beverage - Decaf Coffee
$3.90
Beverage - Coffee
$3.90

Milkshakes  

Milkshake - Milkshake (Regular Size)
Classic vanilla, chocolate madness, strawberry sweetness, or gooey caramel.
$7.74
Milkshake - Milkshake (Kids' Size)
Classic vanilla, chocolate madness, strawberry sweetness, or gooey caramel.
$5.14

We offer delivery for this restaurant.

Ordering Hours

Sunday11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Monday11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Thursday11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Friday11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
Saturday11:00 AM - 9:30 PM

Browse By Cities

Browse By Restaurants

Navigate

Account

Useful Links

Partner With Us

Connect With Us

Hours

  • Sunday 
    12:00pm - 9:00pm
  • Mon-Fri:
  • 11:00am - 9:00pm
  • Saturday:
    4:00pm - 9:00pm